Stanley Fish's critics disagree about him. He is an "intellectual boot-boy", a "trafficker in scurrility, effrontery, and every low rhetorical trick", "a happy gamesman" with a "disturbingly radical agenda". He is a jury-rigger, a dangerous populist, an open cynic and a self-declared sophist. And he is "the most quoted, most controversial, most in-demand and most feared English teacher in the world". The Stanley Fish Reader assembles for the first...