The Great Heresy

by Arthur Guirdham

Book Overview

A study of the history and beliefs of Catharism. This description may be from another edition of this product.

• Format: Paperback
• Language: English
• ISBN: 0852072716
• ISBN13: 9780852072714
• Release Date: January 1993
• Publisher: C W Daniel Company
• Length: 192 Pages
• Weight: 0.05 lbs.
• Dimensions: 0.6" x 5.3" x 8.4"

Customer Reviews

Only truth could have provoked such a diabolical suppression

Arthur Guirdham. The Great Heresy. Saffron Walden: The C.W. Daniel Company Limited, 1993 (1970). Paperback, 186 pages. ISBN 0852072716 Books about Catharism tend to be of two kinds. Serious studies of this magnificent efflorescence of Gnosticism in Medieval Languedoc seem to have been produced almost exclusively by French scholars and are of course in French, while many of the more popular treatments in English have tended towards the fanciful and sensationalistic. Given this, Guirdham's rich and fascinating book comes as a welcome surprise. Although, in a sense, a 'popular' treatment in that he has not cluttered his book with footnotes and other scholarly paraphernalia, it is at the same time a serious and valuable account of the origin, history, philosophy, beliefs, practices and final suppression of the Cathars insofar as they can be known today, and one based on a thorough knowledge of both the scholarly sources and the extant artefacts. It is also an objective, fair-minded, and extremely well-written book. Readers who are themselves fair-minded will find in this book a feast that will enrich them in many ways. Among other things, it certainly led me to understand what true religion should look like, and what a tragedy it was for the world that Catharism and the amazingly advanced civilization it gave rise to were suppressed by the Roman international theocracy with a brutality and viciousness so horrible it is impossible to find words to describe it other than to say it could only have been diabolically inspired. Finally, readers should beware the hostile reviews of books on the Cathars as these can come from the orthodox camp which today have to content themselves with scoffs, smears and lies but which in the old days (on the authority of John 15.6) used to burn people to death for holding different beliefs.

More understanding of Cathar beliefs

I read this book hoping to learn more about Cathar beliefs. I had a smattering of knowledge and wanted more, but I was looking for real information, not comdemnation and half truths. I got what I was looking for. I got an indepth description of the facets of everday Catharism and descriptions of the more educated/trained Cathars. It was entertaining and informative reading. The second part of the book was quite eye-opening for me. It was interesting to see/read the thoughts of the returned CAthars. I found the thoughts presented there to be quite thought provoking. All in all a good read and worth the cost.

The Cathars, Alice Bailey, Ken Carey... I see a pattern

Arthur Guirdham's historic research (dates, characters, events) of the condemnation of the Cathars is consistent with research by Picknett and Prince in "The Templar Revelation..." and Starbird's "The Woman with an Alabaster Jar: Mary Magdalene...". However, where it differs significantly is that Arthur Guirdham displayed the ability to embrace the esoteric and higher consciousness. What he writes of the philosphy and beliefs of the Cathars can be compared in part to the writings of Alice A. Bailey (e.g. The Seven Rays) and Key Carey (e.g. The Third Millenium). As the souls on Earth who reach this higher level of consciousness are outnumbered by those who do not, it is not surprising to see how condemnation occurs, not only in the 13th century Crusades and Inquisition, but in the 20th century by unenlightened readers (e.g. the reviewer from Berkeley).