Rommel: Battles and Campaigns

by Kenneth John Macksey

Book Overview

Although--like Hannibal, Napoleon, and Robert E. Lee--German Field Marshal Erwin Rommel (1891-1944) met ultimately with defeat, his daring, tactical skill, charismatic leadership, and brilliant string... This description may be from another edition of this product.

• Format: Hardcover
• Language: English
• ISBN: 0831774770
• ISBN13: 9780831774776
• Release Date: January 1979
• Publisher: Smithmark Pub
• Length: 224 Pages
• Weight: 1.68 lbs.

Customer Reviews

Rommel did also mistakes

Kenneth Macksey is not the kind of writer who will produce a repetition of existing arguments and bore the reader. It is true that he looks at Rommel with a very critical view but that is what I expect from an expert on World War II who is very accurate and does extensive research for his books. Don't let bad critics to keep you away from this book, because it's a terrific factual short account of Rommel's meteoric carreer and not an hagiography of the man. The photo captions are very informative and the maps are numerous and very good.

Rommel- Overrated

Anglo accounts of World War Two frequently sing the praises of Rommel and his victories. Reality? Rommel was second rate for the Germans, and got his job, and promotions largely due to propaganda reasons and friendship with Hitler. While a tactical genius, and excellent at operations, his stratgic level decision making was poor at best... ignoring logistical realities and the larger strategic picture. Rommel's job in the sand was to hold off the British- not conquor the Middle East. He failed, largely due to ignore logistics. Macksey does an excellent job reviewing Rommel's life and accurately pointing out his strenghs and weaknesses. If you are looking for a honest appraisal of Rommel, buy this book. If you a Rommel fan-boy, don't.

An Interesting Perspective

Kenneth Macksey, in his biography Rommel: Battles and Campaigns, is highly critical or Rommel. Macksey sees Rommel as a leader who changed little about his tactics from the First World War, despite massive technological changes. Macksey believed Rommel had a huge amount of luck in his battles. This differs from most historians' views, with David Frazer (Knight's Cross; HarperCollins) pointing out that war relies to a large extent on luck. There is also the cliché that `you make your own luck'. Macksey views Rommel's advance through France in 1940 critically, and is quick to move acclaim from Rommel to his superiors, fellow generals, and troops. Although Macksey does have examples to support this view, they are highly specific, and are lost in a general evaluation of Rommel's successes. Macksey sees Rommel's success in North Africa as due to the poor leadership of the Allied forces, not the skill of the `Desert Fox'. Frazer again has a different view, and states that in almost every single battle of his African campaign, Rommel was hugely outnumbered, but won some marvelous victories against vastly superior opposition. This was an interesting account, obviously from an anti-Rommel perspective, but giving excellent details on all of Rommel's battles, great maps and visuals as well.