Not So Rotten Ralph

by Jack Gantos

Book Overview

In desperation, Sarah sends Rotten Ralph to feline finishing school. Will Ralph's mischief finally be a thing of the past? This description may be from another edition of this product.

• Format: Paperback
• Language: English
• ISBN: 0395851564
• ISBN13: 9780395851562
• Release Date: January 1997
• Publisher: Harcourt Brace and Company
• Length: 32 Pages
• Weight: 0.65 lbs.
• Dimensions: 0.1" x 9.0" x 8.5"
• Age Range: 5 to 8 years
• Grade Range: Preschool to Grade 3

Customer Reviews

Another in a Long Line of Rotten Ralph Laugh Fests

Let's get to the offending line right away: "When they got home, Sarah awarded Ralph with a celebration." That's it. "Awarded," not "rewarded." If that's proof of our declining educational system and cannot be tolerated, skip the book. If you do, however, you'll be missing one of the funniest of the Rotten Ralph books, with a great story line by Jack Gantos, and elaborate, very creative pictures by the ultra-talented Nicole Rubel, one of my favorite illustrators. Before I get into the specifics, I offer the following teacher- and parent-friendly suggestions for "dealing" with the whole award/reward controversy. 1. Teach the difference between "award" and "reward." 2. Ask about other commonly confused words. 3. Have your students write a story with a "hidden" mistake; ask others to find it! 4. (Older students) Talk about the book publishing industry, and how and why this diction mistake might have happened. 5. Ignore it, because young kids won't notice it, and if they do, their teachers will teach them proper usage later. 6. Explain that cats do not know the word "reward," instead, they always use "award." Rotten Ralph is a mischievous, fun-loving cat, but he's also willful, a bad listener, and a little on the destructive side. We're not talking felonious feline, just pranks like spraying whipped cream all over the kitchen, spraying the postman with water so that "the mail flew all over" (OK, that MIGHT be a federal crime), and flapping flapjacks and batter all over the kitchen. Sarah, his owner, decides that "Mr. Fred's Feline Finishing School" might teach Ralph a few social niceties. Ralph reluctantly agrees; there's a very funny picture of Fred dragging Ralph into the school while Ralph digs his claw into the floor trying to stay out. While in school, Ralph flouts all the social conventions that Fred (another cat, with wounds from former students) teaches: Contrary to Mr. Fred's direct instructions, he burps loudly and touches and breaks some of the many whimsical objets d'art that Rubel places in the "SELF-CONTROL ROOM." Finally, in a move that much older students might discuss in terms of HIPAA regulations (see, this is an educational book, even WITH the wrong word!), Fred hypnotizes Ralph into being a good cat. It works too well: When Sarah rewards/awards Ralph with a graduation party, he just falls asleep, instead of being his usual "life of the party" self. In a clever role reversal, certain to get big laughs from your audience, Sarah tries to teach him some of his old tricks. "She chased a mouse. She climbed the curtains. She even ate a goldfish.... She lifted him on the chandelier and gave him a push." Swinging on the fixture (for clinical graduate students: Does this induce a counter-hypnotic state?), Ralph finally realizes how good being rotten feels. He sticks out his tongue at Sarah, and gives a rotten growl. Sarah is delighted to have her Rotten Ralph back, and gives him a big hug. Ralph's glad too, "as he ripped up his

Another great Rotten Ralph story!

"Not so Rotten Ralph" is one of my favorite books of the series. My five year old brother laughs and laughs each time we read it! The illustrator again adds to the plot with cleaver details - tell your child to pay close attention to the pictures!