Interrogations: The Nazi Elite in Allied Hands, 1945

by Richard Overy

Book Overview

While the trial of Hitler's fallen elite at Nuremberg has been thoroughly documented, the interval between the Nazis' capture in May and June 1945 and the start of the actual trial in late November... This description may be from another edition of this product.

• Format: Hardcover
• Language: English
• ISBN: 0670030082
• ISBN13: 9780670030088
• Release Date: October 2001
• Publisher: Viking Books
• Length: 320 Pages
• Weight: 2.40 lbs.
• Dimensions: 1.7" x 6.4" x 9.6"

Customer Reviews

Mentality of Atrocity

I guess most people ask themselves at some time, how do rational, seemingly decent human beings come to the point of sanctioning, organising and then carrying out the systematic destruction of around 11 million people, (give or take), with 6 million of them being Jewish? It is a tough one, and it is even tougher to understand, should one even want to try understanding it. "Interrogations" by Richard Overy goes some way into seeing how those brought to trial at Nuremberg dealt with the reality of what they had done and how they tried to explain it. The book gives some background information on the charges brought against them, the people carrying out the interrogations and so on. There are a couple of chapters on individuals such as Goering, Hess and Von Papen. Other chapters are based on topical issues, like genocide, Hitler himself, and so on. It is interesting the way which legal implications of the trials developed. One example is the way in which organisations themselves were deemed "criminal" and then anyone associated with them was open to arrest. The Nazi prisoners protested the move, of course. Of the individuals, I found Goering the most fascinating, in the sense that he did not seem to attempt any avoidance of responsibility. Others tried to distance themselves, or in the case of Speer, tried to show himself as a neutral civil servant. Goering never seemed to do that, and just accepted his part in it. People interested in the Nazi phenomena and the Holocaust of the Jews and other victims of the Nazi death camps, "Interrogations" is "essential reading", as another reviewer stated. Thoroughly engrossing and thoroughly recommended.

Chilling, insightful

There has been much analysis of the deeds, motives and consequences of Germany's Nazis, some of it brilliant, some of it rubbish, much in between. But there is simply no substitute for their actual words. Thanks to the exhaustive interviews conducted by the allies prepatory to the Nuremberg trials and the organizing and editing skills of Richard Overy, today's readers have easy access to many of those words. "Interrogations" lays bare the banality of evil, the chilling hate and the mindless obedience of Nazi war criminals. They also present a comprehensive account of the workings of Nazi Germany, including the leadership of Adolph Hitler. More so then in his own writings, Hitler's architect, Albert Speer provides a richly detailed account of his and Hitler's activities and mindset. Indeed the mindset of the various interviewees is compelling subject matter to ponder. Many seem to realize in retrospect what a terrible mistake they had made. They practically seem to be speaking of someone else as they openly discuss their participation in the horrors of the Nazi regime. The detestable Herman Goring is an exception suggesting no regrets about actions or beliefs. The book is divided by subject matter, including genocide, perspectives on Hitler, the waging of War and Rudolph Hess. Those interrogated include Speer, Goering, Joachin von Ribbentorp and Alfred Jodl. Overy does a masterful job of introducing the topics and the people, providing background and perspectives. "Interrogations" is an important addition to the library of any student of World War II and of the Holocaust. It also stands well by itself as a fascinating study of human nature at its most destructive.

Confessions: in their own words.

"Interrogation: The Nazi Elite in Allied Hands, 1945" is a disturbing and enlightening book. It collect the transcription of the interrogations, put to different Nazi leaders, very soon after they were captured and before they were submitted to trial. The book address in the first part, the main issues with which the Allied were confronted, in order to mount a trial for the War Criminals. British, American and Russians, the French were incorporated later, had very different points of view and criteria as how to perform this. Who were to be indicted; which should be the charges; which will be the legislation used; who should preside the Court; who will conduct the defense; etc. These and other substantial points were being discussed even before the end of the war. As soon as the peace was signed, all Intelligence forces started to search for the Nazi leaders. Some were captured without problem. Some committed suicide before being caught or immediately after. They were disseminated in very different kind of prisons and receiving different treatment. Finally agreement between the Allies is attained and a common list of War Criminals produced. Once they were all rallied in one prison, they were subjected to interrogation, with a standard protocol and rules. The second part of this work centers on the transcriptions of these interviews.A very rich material emerges here. Curiously, much of it was not used in the trials, so it is little known to the great public. From this notes, Overy, wisely select and present very significant excerpts to the reader. He grouped them thematically and adds some personal comments. Different personalities and strategies from the defendant are shown: Göring boisterous and unremorseful; Hesse faking madness; Ribbentrop trying to look confused, overwhelmed by Hitler's power; Speer pleading some guilt and penitence. A gallery of dubious characters trying to survive blaming Hitler and deflecting their guilt. The depositions of the responsible of the extermination camps are devastating: they really can not grasp the horror of what they have done. A book to read in order to have some understanding of a dark period of Human history. Lastly, the hardback edition is a very beautiful object in itself, first quality paper and printing is used. Reviewed by Max Yofre.

"Records were made to be broken" -- Woody Allen<br>

There are a lot of Nazi wannabees in the world, and many of them claim that the Holocaust never happened, or more insidiously, that the Holocaust was "exaggerated" (whatever the blank that meants). There's a book of interrogation transcripts taken from Nazis after the war. It is not pleasant reading. I do wonder, in this age of PC, whether the public school system actually teaches about the Holocaust and the stupidity of Holocaust deniers.Dieter Wisliceny, one of Eichmann's lieutenants, put the number of Jews exterminated at 4,817,700, based on personal recollection and while looking at a table (not reproduced) showing the numbers from this or that country or part of a country. He doesn't mention the Ukraine, where another 500,000 or more were killed by mobile SS units, or Germany, where his figure of 180,000 appears much too low. He does recount that Eichmann told him that Polish Jewry were the powerhouse for world Jewry and were to be completely exterminated. That amounts to over 3 million killed."I am convinced that with the exception of the few thousands of Polish Jews found alive in concentration camps, every single Polish Jewish individual has been killed." -- Wisliceny (p 368)Another interrogation (more like a conversation) between two other people has the disturbing scene in which they begin to laugh as they recount how bad the area near the killing rooms smelled, but how it got to the point where one could eat a sandwich in there. That conversation ends with the man being interrogated saying that the only good thing that came out of the project was that a few million Jews were killed.Dr. Robert Ley, a notorious and self-proclaimed anti-Semite wrote an open letter to the German people saying that the Jews and Germans had to make peace with one another, but he did so in such a slimy, unrepentant, ambivalent way that I got a little sick reading it. That [characterization deleted] killed himself in his cell rather than be tried for his criminal activities.Other than the Holocaust, another subject somewhat illuminated by these transcripts is the conduct of the war, and the reasons behind some obvious tactical and strategic mistakes by Germany, most notably its failure to invade Britain and end the threat of a two front war. Hitler and others were concerned that the British Navy was too strong for Germany to invade. And yet, Germany opened up a second front before it was ready (if indeed it ever could have been) rather than prepare the UK invasion.Keitel said that if the USSR could have been overcome by 1941 and forced to capitulate all would have been fine, and that he'd held that view at the outset. He also noted that Germany had only six divisions on the eastern front after the division of Poland, and that continuous guerrila warfare was going on, along with a massive buildup of Soviet forces, and increasing territorial and other demands that Hitler couldn't accept. Had the non-aggression pact not been signed, or Stalin's bluff