I Saw Esau: The Schoolchild's Pocket Book

by Iona Opie and Peter Opie

Book Overview

"The mood is insouciant glee. A treasure." -- Kirkus Reviews (starred review)"Sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me." That's what children chant when they are being... This description may be from another edition of this product.

• Format: Hardcover
• Language: English
• ISBN: 1564020460
• ISBN13: 9781564020468
• Release Date: June 1992
• Publisher: Candlewick Press (MA)
• Length: 160 Pages
• Weight: 0.96 lbs.
• Dimensions: 1.2" x 5.6" x 7.7"
• Age Range: 6 to 9 years
• Grade Range: Grades 1 to 4

Customer Reviews

Tops Dr. Suess Any Day!

My daughter loves this books. Its collection of old, silly nursery rhymes and poetry are funny and enjoyable for both children and parents to read. Great for any kid who's too sophisticated for the average poetry book.

Get one for your kids, one four yourself, and five for your school library.

Peter and Iona Opie (eds.), I Saw Esau: The Schoolchild's Pocket Book (Revised Edition) (Candlewick Press, 1992) It will come as no surprise to anyone who's read I Saw Esau: The Schoolchild's Pocket Book that it has been challenged as "obscene" in Murfreesboro, TN (viz. The Murfreesboro Daily News Journal, Feb. 7, 2007). I Saw Esau is exactly the kind of book that begs a challenge. First it's illustrated by the wonderful Maurice Sendak, who seems to trail controversy wherever he goes. Second, the Opies actually collected the rhymes, sayings, and other nonesuch here from actual children, and of course, children must be protected from anything else said by their real-world contemporaries. After all, morons who challenge kids' books in schools either never were kids, have forgotten what being a kid was like, or are such humorless sticks-in-the-mud that they don't feel their own children deserve to have as fun a childhood as they did. (Any other interpretations of such boorish behavior-- and they are legion-- would verge on libel, and thus will not be speculated upon here.) If, on the other hand, you're a reasonable, thinking human being who has a shred of a sense of humor and are old enough to remember where you were when JFK was shot, and perhaps if you're a bit younger and hung around with people older than you were as a kid, you're going to recognize a lot of what's in here, probably with great fondness. You chanted this stuff, or variations on it, as a kid in the schoolyard. Maurice Sendak's illustrations complement the text wonderfully, often in frighteningly literal manner, and are never less than a pleasure. (But, oh, horrors, one must protect one's children from naked gluteus maximi that appear on a few pages! And oh, how terrible, one drawing features full frontal nudity! Well, tell me-- do YOU take a bath with your clothes on?) If you're younger than that, you'll probably be able to see the germs of your own schoolyard babblings in here, and be equally charmed. If you read it and are offended by it, then you may well be one of that subset of people who simply needs to be offended until you get it. In any case, I can't recommend this book highly enough, both for yourself and to share with your kids. ****

a sentimental favorite

I received this book for my fourth Christmas from a beloved uncle, and it has stayed with me in a cherished position ever since (though granted, that's only been about a decade and a half). Although I doubt Opie's comment that all children need to know some rhymes by which to gain popularity is entirely accurate for the playground of today, a well-placed rhyme did mark a few points of my childhood, and helped me to realize that such fools as could not appreciate the absurdity of Moses Supposes, or Eaper Weeper, chimney sweeper, weren't worth my time. Even now I regale acquiantances and friends with the likes of that cruel husband, and even if the lines I've memorized weren't worthwhile in themselves, the endnotes of the book including such tidbits as the meaning of antiquated references and the origins of certain rhymes (many hail back from the 17th century) would be. For the more pragmatic, I could also make an argument that the older poems helped generate a familiarity with less modern texts which aided my lexical understanding and appreciation for dark humor and love for words, but that could be going to far. I get awfully sentimental about this book though, and I want you to buy a copy.

I Saw Esau

A delightful book for kids of all ages! Each page of this book has delightful, light, charming prose. The illustrations by Maurice Sendak put the final touches on a lovely, well-bound volume of reading for a family to share or a child to escape to a cozy window-seat and read. I recommend this book for someone who wants to give a nice, lasting gift to a special child or friend.