Food, Inc.: Mendel to Monsanto--The Promises and Perils of the Biotech Harvest

by Peter Pringle

Book Overview

A balanced and well-researched account of the dispute over genetically modified foods. The British government must make a decision by Spring 2004 as to where the UK stands in this matter and the author exposes the propaganda science and fear-mongering so prevalent in this issue.

• Format: Hardcover
• Language: English
• ISBN: 0743226119
• ISBN13: 9780743226110
• Release Date: June 2003
• Publisher: Simon & Schuster
• Length: 239 Pages
• Weight: 1.06 lbs.
• Dimensions: 0.9" x 6.3" x 9.6"

Customer Reviews

Live with Health, not medicine

This book and the movie that goes with it are awesome. Everyone should be growing and eating their own food to the extent possible to them. They should be buying from local farmers who use sustainable, chemical free methods. I also recommend: Animal Vegetable Miracle 1ST Edition Eath healthy and live drug [prescription medicines] free!

very insightful and concise

I recommend it highly to anyone interested in reading about biotechnology and the food we eat

From a Science view

I am often frustrated by the bias nature of these books, I was very impressed by the authors work. Having a science background and working in the biotech arena, I appreciated the factual information that did not seem to promote the anit-GE view that much of the literature in the area does (like I said, a very balanced report). It is written at a level that most people will be able to understand and is very entertaining. This book is great no matter what side of the debate you stand on and I highly recomend it .

Interesting introduction into the world of biotech foods

Is the food supply really safe? Does our government look out for the interest of the consumer and the environment or is it in the hip pocket of the giant corporations? Being a totally non-scientific person, I had to struggle with terminology in this discussion of the pros and cons of genetically altered crops. Pringle does a reasonably good job of presenting both sides of the argument in the simplest terms possible. He also does a fine job of sprinkling in some of the history of the debate, defining who the players are and assessing the political landscape. For example, did you know that caffeine genes have been inserted into soybeans? Think of the enormous worldwide economic implications if coffee could suddenly be grown in North Dakota. What about the consequences of human beings and animals consuming genetically altered foods? And were you aware that the existence of the much beloved monarch butterfly is threatened by genetically altered crops? These are the kinds of topics explored here. It is the kind of book that makes you want to learn more about these very important issues. Recommended.

Many Sides of a Complicated Problem

One of the hardest contemporary stories to cover is genetically modified food. It is tangled with pure science, technology, industrialization, profiteering, and world politics. In the past ten years, there have been loud boasts and loud denunciations about GM crops. Those who invent and stand to profit from new herbicide-resistant, insect-resistant, salt-resistant, nutrient-added species have promised that farmers, starving third-world children, and the environment will all be benefited. On the other side are those equally insistent that "Frankenfood" promises nothing but superweeds, distorted genomes for traditional crops, allergies, decimation of fauna, and benefit to no one but giant corporations. Peter Pringle has entered this zone of contention almost like a war correspondent, and his bulletins from the front form _Food, Inc.: Mendel to Monsanto - The Promises and Perils of the Biotech Harvest_ (Simon & Schuster). Pringle has tried not to take sides, but to report on the curiosities, colorful characters, and paradoxes of the new technology. Because of this, the volume will probably be unsatisfactory to anyone with strong feelings on one side or the other, but it is a good overall look at the controversy. Pringle insists that people are going to have to make informed decisions on these issues, and his book is a good step in that direction. Pringle starts with the story of Ingo Potrykus, one of the researchers who invented "golden rice." Potrykus coaxed genes from daffodils (of all things) into rice so that the grains contained beta carotene, which can be converted in the body to vitamin A. Getting the vitamin to third-worlders who didn't have it was supposed to put a humanitarian face on the worrisome technology. It didn't happen because a mega-company had to be paid off, and the biotech industry was accused of various other infractions. While Pringle certainly covers the overreactions of anti-biotech forces, he has the most criticism for Monsanto and its fellow corporations. He gives many examples of how GM food has been cavalierly treated and regulated. There is potential that GM crops might help us, but we are stumbling. Environmental activists shout whenever there is any product from GM agriculture, and the corporations have a skuzzy record of bullying Mexican bean importers and Canadian rapeseed growers for punitive royalties, as well as lying about the possible dangers of the crops. The dangers are considerable; what is going to happen, for instance, when genes to produce medicines are inserted into our grain and we get tetanus vaccine in our corn flakes? The industry has done so bad of job of safety issues that rightly or wrongly, the European Union will not import GM plants, and starving Zimbabwe has refused relief from GM corn. There is surprisingly little evidence that GM crops actually help in any way; even the financial benefits of Bt crops have been no better than marginal. The problems are not going to go awa