It always rains on the same day once a year in the small town of Quiet Creeks, and Sandy Hawkins keeps her tradition alive during that certain day, with a fresh baked cherry pie, chocolate milk, and a particular song on the record player - just as well as she keeps her grim secret hidden - until her boyfriend Alan Haze begins to suspect something eerie about Sandy, causing him to go as far as restlessly searching through headstones at the towns cemetery...