You seem to discredit it on the basis that it's romantic in nature, rather than philosophical, dramatic, or whatever it is that you consider good about Replay. But it's not as though this is a trashy harlequin romance novel with some tempestuous scene dipicted on the cover, rampant with heaving bosoms and the like. Mostly, I disagree with your contention that fans of replay are going to be disappointed by Elise. Both I, and the reviewer on the top of this page, enjoyed both. So many people complain about unoriginality in art--why do you seem to want the artist to find a comfortable rut?
More than just romance
Published by Thriftbooks.com User , 21 years ago
I read Elise after reading an obituary on author Ken Grimwood, in which the plot outlines of a few of his books were mentioned. I opted to read Replay, Breakthrough, and Elise. Replay was just fantastic, a terrific read. Breakthrough was a tough read, as I found most of it boring, and this was the true romance book of the three. I enjoyed Elise as much as I did Replay. The book was liking watching a movie, and Grimwood's plot was plausible, even his explanation of why the protagonist was immortal. Since the book was about a woman, it did have some romance, but the major point of the book I think, was the mixed feelings that come with being immortal. This book makes you think about life and death, and was superbly written. Grimwood was a true master wordsmith, and it's a pity that he died so soon, and ironic considering the subject matter of his books. My main question after reading these great novels is why haven't they been made into movies? The plots are far more interesting and intriguing than most of the junk seen in theatres today.
ThriftBooks sells millions of used books at the lowest everyday prices. We personally assess every book's quality and offer rare, out-of-print treasures. We deliver the joy of reading in recyclable packaging with free standard shipping on US orders over $15. ThriftBooks.com. Read more. Spend less.