Celebrating Middle-earth: The Lord of the Rings as a Defense of Western Civilization

by Joseph Pearce and Peter Kreeft

Book Overview

In Celebrating Middle-earth six writers explore the important place that J. R. R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings occupies in the literary, political and religious traditions of Western society. Those... This description may be from another edition of this product.

• Format: Paperback
• Language: English
• ISBN: 1587420120
• ISBN13: 9781587420122
• Release Date: June 2002
• Publisher: Inkling Books
• Length: 108 Pages
• Weight: 1.30 lbs.
• Dimensions: 0.3" x 6.2" x 9.1"

Customer Reviews

Tolkien -- A Defender of Western Civilization +++

Before reading "Celebrating Middle-Earth" -- and before reading other commentary works on LOTR [Lord of the Rings] -- I saw Tolkien as a defender of Western Civilization -- as well as warning of excess -- such as power, greed, warfare and over-mining. LOTR [and "The Silmarillion"] is Creatively composed of some main cultural components of "The West" -- such as various Judeo-Christian, Greco-Roman, Celto-Nordic, Finnish, and even Amerindian aspects. This includes cultural-aspects, language-aspects -- and saga-apects of individuals making freewill choices as they venture and adventure into danger to save Middle-Earth. But, yes, "Celebrating Middle Earth" does have a strong bias towards "Christendom" -- as did "The West" until recently. "Christendom" itself is composed of various influences -- even likely some from Old Egypt -- but including many of the very same aspects as LOTR. By all that I have seen, Tolkien did view himself as a defender of "The West" -- and was a practicing Catholic -- yet was very inclusive of those cultures already noted. This Great Author despised intolerence as noted by other reviewers. That so many folks of various backgrounds can find Inspiration via LOTR and Tolkien -- shows his rich, wide and deep aspects -- including the six authors of the chapters of this book. The very first chapter is authored by the editor, John G. West, and has the same title as the subtitle of the whole book -- "The Lord of the Rings as a Defense of Western Civilization" -- and makes this case rationally in detail. The front page has an explanation at bottom -- "An Examination of the Writings of J. R. R. Tolkien as a Defense of the Literary, Philosophical, Political, and Religious Foundations of Western Society" -- that I hope others will verify via reading this book. When Tolkien first studied and wrote, it was still broadly understood that "The West" and "Christendom" overlaped greatly, if not totally -- as there were Greek, Orthodox, Armenian, Coptic and Celtic variants of "Christendom". Nowadays, new variants of the old ones are developing in large parts of the world -- along with the continuing momentum, of "The West" -- which seems to do much better in a non-imperial era and way. For those that favor individualism, responsibilty, opportunity, democracy, diversity, natural and human law, "The West" and its momentum may be worth defending -- in an interlinked richly cultured world. This little book is a great intoduction to Tolkien and LOTR study that seems to follow Tolkien closely -- including his "Personal Theology" as well as other major aspects +++

kindred spirits

Some may "grit their teeth" (as one disgruntled reviewer said below) through these essays, but readers more in tune with Tolkien's own philosophy will be pleased to find these kindred spirits. Virtually every political and cultural movement of the past forty years, from free-spirited hippies in the '60s, to strident environmentalists in the '70s, to Christian fundamentalists in the new millennium. has tried to co-opt Tolkien's books as emblematic of their particular concerns. It is a testament to the richness of his work that people from such disparate viewpoints see therein a reflection of their beliefs. Those from the left side of the political spectrum sometimes seem to want to wish away the truth, but the fact is, Tolkien was a Catholic conservative, in virtually every sense of the word. He attended Mass almost daily; he was a staunch member of the Conservative Party and an anti-Communist; and he abhorred Big Government almost more than anything else. Of course, this doesn't mean that these works cannot be enjoyed by those who disagree with these views. But surely there is room in this world for books written about Tolkien and his work by those who sympathize with his views -- which describes this particular slim volume -- just as there is room for those who don't. If you're looking for something critical of Tolkien's core beliefs, this isn't the book for you. But if you're simpatico, or just curious and open-minded (quel surprise!) about what truly made him tick, give this collection a try. Peter Kreeft's essay alone is worth the modest price. Tolkien may have been conservative to the core, but he was by no means a racist (he famously said in his valedictory speech at Oxford, "I have the hatred of apartheid in my bones" -- many years before that view became fashionable). He surely didn't see the defense of Western civilization as synonymous with racism, as, sadly, too many fashionably relativistic "multi-culturalists" now claim. He didn't love war, but he understood well the folly of burying one's head in the sand. (See the encounter between Gandalf and the Saruman-enchanted Theoden in "The Two Towers" for a startling parallel to contemporary debate.) If you're an unbending pacifistic atheist, you may not like what you read here. But then, Tolkien probably wouldn't cotton to your point of view either. I'm not saying this to be critical of my friends on the left. But learn more about the man himself, and you will have to agree. This book is a good place to start.

Good but needs expansion

This is a vey good book but perhaps too focussed on Christian values for the title to be fully correct. Hal Colebatch's "Return of the Heroes: The Lord of the Rings, Star Wars, Harry Potter and Social Conflict," which I have reviewed on its own page, does a much more comprehensive job in looking at the relationship between TLOTR and the whole of Western as well as specifically Christian values. Both, however, are full of interest and recommended.

New Insights

While all six essays in this slender volume will prove of interest to the reader seeking more background on J.R.R. Tolkien's epic story, I found the essay by Janet Blumberg, "The Literary Background of The Lord of the Rings" especially valuable. Prof. Blumberg not only explains the influences of Anglo-Saxon literature such as "Beowulf" and High Medieval literature such as "Sir Gawain and the Green knight" on elements in LOTR, but also offers a credible explanation for one of the most remarked about elements in the books: the absence of any overt religious practice or worship. This essay alone makes this slender volume a valuable addition to the library of any Tolkien fan.