Biblical Fundamentalism: What Every Catholic Should Know

by Ronald D. Witherup

Book Overview

2002 Catholic Press Association Award Winner!

One of the most significant changes initiated by the Second Vatican Council was the direct encouragement for Catholics to rediscover the Bible. Unfortunately, education has lagged behind Catholic interest in exploring the Bible and its mysteries. Consequently, vital questions, including how to read and interpret the Bible, remain unanswered for many Christians. In Biblical Fundamentalism,...

• Format: Paperback
• Language: English
• ISBN: 0814627226
• ISBN13: 9780814627228
• Release Date: October 2001
• Publisher: Liturgical Press
• Length: 104 Pages
• Weight: 0.35 lbs.
• Dimensions: 0.4" x 5.4" x 8.3"

Customer Reviews

Excellent Resource

I urge all readers and reviewers to disregard the review from "a reader" entitled "A Very Shallow Book." Witherup's book is dead on accurate. I have first-hand reason to know. I'm an ex-evangelical/fundamentalist who converted to the Roman Catholic faith four years ago. Everything Witherup says about fundamentalism, especially the manner in which it approaches scripture, is true. The reviewer makes the absurd assertion that Witherup hasn't taken the time to TRY to understand fundamentalism. On the contrary, as someone who came out of fundamentalism, I can attest he understands it quite thoroughly. The only reason I didn't give it five stars is I wish Witherup had gone into more details, specifically on the subject of how scriptures are interpreted and applied to daily living by fundamentalists and how their approach so often leads to erroneous conclusions about what the Bible says. For example, in Proverbs, it says "Wine is a mocker, strong drink is raging and whosoever is decieved thereby is not wise." Fundamentalists use this scripture as the basis for their contention that any alcohol consumption is sinful. But that passage doesn't specifically say it's wrong to drink alcohol. You can't get "Thou shalt not drink any alcoholic beverage of any kind, any time or anywhere" out of "Wine is a mocker" unless you're reading something into that passage that just isn't there. I could go on with countless examples of how fundamentalists misinterpret, misuse and misapply scripture, many of which would be from my own personal experiences. But that is beyond the scope and intent of this review. Suffice to say, if you want a quick and short resource to refute fundamentalism's approach, Witherup's book is an excellent start, especially if you're a "Cradel Catholic" and find yourself speechless when confronted with fundamentalist "arguments."

Educational for people who want to understand the Church

This is one of the best books I've read that explains the Catholic view of the Bible and the difference from fundamentalists or Evangelical Christians. This book is especially informative to the educated, thinkers, and people who have a hard time with religion in the modern world. What I enjoyed most was that the book showed what the Bible is really about and portrays that not every Christian is ignorant and anti-science. Many people that use reason as part of their faith want to go to church without committing intellectual suicide. This book is a good place to start. ( Also check Marcus Borg)

A good start: Here, private communication from author

I read the other reviews and I succeeded in one email exchange with the author.The author's goal was an introduction, a brief but concise comparison of fundamentalist and Catholic views on the Bible. He has succeeded in making the basic distinction. I think and told him that he doesn't offer alternative interpretations to the texts of Scripture where the greatest differences exist with fundamentalists.Catholic biblical scholarship indeed comes across as a type of modernism, disrespecting centuries of Catholic Church teaching and precedent. He satisfies himself to paint a fairly accurate picture of the fundamentalists' view of scripture and then offers a thumbnail sketch of the Catholic view, without many specifics. By email, he referred me to the (mostly Catholic) bibliography of his book for further information. I take exception to one of his more controversial assertions, That fundamentalists tend to canonize social relationships in the bible that in fact were simply accidents of their historical context. In other words, the subservient position of women in the bible is not a precept of the bible, but just a reflection of the times of the writer. This idea is clearly stated as a difference of Catholics and Fundamentalists, but it is poorly motivated.By private communication he says: "The Bible does not contain fiction (as we moderns would define it) as such, but not everything in the Bible is history either. Your examples of Jonah or Ruth or Esther are narrative stories with various moral and/or heroic themes in them, and Genesis 1-11 is myth (not fiction) with an important theological perspective to it. "Myth" here does not mean an untrue story but a narrative with a profoundly true message, couched in ordinary story language. Fundamentalists, too, can recognize that some stories are not meant to be literally true (they are not all literalists), depending on the literary genre of the story, though they tend to read Gen 1-11 as historically and scientifically true, in contrast to non-fundamentalist approaches."

Put this in your required reading stack

This is an excellent summary of Fundamentalism vis-a-vis Catholic beliefs; I strongly recommend it for any interested layman or laywoman who wants a concise reference. The writing is intelligent, succinct, accessible for readers of all levels and experience. Would make a great gift.

THIS BOOK IS REALLY WORTH READING

This is an excellent book. It gives a good perspective of Fundamentalist and Catholic beliefs. It is for members of both faiths who want to learn more about the faith of each other. It is well written by a highly educated man. I believe members of both faiths would benefit from reading this book.GregDanville Holy Family Parish