In 1900, sharpshooter Annie Oakley, "the most famous woman in the world" still performs with Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show, but when the touring season is over, she lives a quiet life in bucolic Nutley, New Jersey. Childless, Annie has a special interest in orphans, and she's developed a close mentoring relationship with a young girl named Lizzy Miller. One day, Lizzy sees the town librarian fall to her death from the Centre Bridge...