A newcomer, a scandal, a secret baby, can the Faith's Creek Quilting Circle make their next love match? Clara Mast has fled Idaho amidst a scandal. She returned from her Rumspringa, with more than she bargained for, but was she to blame? Unable to handle the way she is treated she travels to Faith's Creek for a new start. Jesse Zook's sisters are visiting from Idaho. Though he tries to be nice, he can't wait for the spiteful women...