- A Retrospect On the Ministry and Church of Saybrook: A Half Century Sermon
- A sermon, delivered at the installation of Pythagoras Lodge, of Free Masons; in Lyme, Connecticut. October 7th, 1800. By Frederick W. Hotchkiss, A.M. ... Say-brook. [Five lines from Magaw's Oration]
- An oration delivered at Saybrook on Saturday February 22d, 1800; the day set apart by the recommendation of Congress for the people of the United ... for the death of General George Washington
- On national greatness. A thanksgiving sermon, delivered to the First Society in Say-Brook, November 29th, 1792. Frederick W. Hotchkiss, A.M. Pastor of the First Church in Say-Brook.
- A Retrospect on the Ministry and Church of Saybrook: A Half Century Sermon, Preached on Lord's Day, September 22, 1833.